Real estate prices keep rising sharply, experts clearly point out the reasons

According to experts, there is currently a reality that, compared with income, real estate prices in Vietnam are too high. This is due to high demand, a large supply-demand gap, scarcity of products, and it is also a consequence of legal obstacles.

At the Conference on contributing opinions to amend policies and laws to develop housing and the real estate market organized by VNREA (Vietnam Real Estate Association), Lawyer Truong Thanh Duc, Arbitrator of the Vietnam International Arbitration Centre, shared that we have amended the law nearly 100 times but the results are still not truly effective.

View of the conference contributing opinions to amend policies and laws to develop housing and the real estate market

“Currently, there is a reality that, compared with income, real estate prices in Vietnam are too high. This is due to high demand, a large supply-demand gap, scarcity of products, and it is also a consequence of legal obstacles.

If demand is high, real estate developers need to balance it. The best way is to allow conversion of other land into residential land to unlock the market. If we block it, and the codes do not go first but are only amended piecemeal, the shortcomings will not be solved. In reality, some projects have been stuck for 10 years because of legal obstacles that cannot be resolved,” the expert said.

According to Mr. Duc, regarding demand, a few years ago it rose only a few percent, but recently real estate demand has risen by several tens of percent while supply has not increased too quickly.

“I think the market must always have a surplus, and if prices keep rising with a lack of supply, that is not a market economy. When supply is short, the law is that prices will rise, causing difficulties and increasing the ask-and-give mechanism,” the expert pointed out.

Lawyer Truong Thanh Duc, Arbitrator of the Vietnam International Arbitration Centre

Many codes have been amended, but whether the amendments are loose or strict is not what matters; what matters is creating a sustainable market instead of a distorted one like today.

Mr. Nguyen Quoc Hiep, Chairman of the Board of Directors of GP Invest, shared that currently, real estate is a complex specialty but has the task of promoting a whole series of other economic sectors, so the real estate market must be unblocked. But according to statistics, there are about 12 laws that directly affect real estate, and up to 60 laws that are related. In terms of administrative procedures, by our calculation a project needs 36 stamps before it is completed. Even, according to one lawyer, there are as many as 120 stamps if unofficial regulations are counted. It can be said that administrative procedures for real estate are extremely complex.

Mr. Nguyen Quoc Hiep, Chairman of the Board of Directors of GP Invest, presents his paper

However, legal procedures are even more complex, which we often call a “matrix”. So how should it be amended? We agree with the view that the Land Law and the Investment Law should be the 2 foundation laws, from which specialized laws take these 2 Laws as the basis for amendment so that things can be unblocked. While the Laws can hardly be made uniform, a foundation law is needed to resolve disputes.

Under the Land Law, the issuance of Decree 30, which does not allow conversion of other land types into residential land, is causing a large number of projects to be stuck (currently about 400 projects in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City are stuck), causing difficulties and obstructing enterprises. Therefore, the first thing is to amend Decree 30.

In addition, the most obstructive issue is the responsibility for site clearance: land clearance is the responsibility of State agencies, not enterprises. This responsibility needs to be clearly resolved.

In addition, there is the matter of land use planning, project approval, land valuation… which also need to be reviewed.

Regarding the Housing Law, first is the apartment issue. The number of apartments in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City is now very large, but the Decree on apartment management is extremely unreasonable.

For apartment warranty, the various codes provide differently, so I think it is necessary to follow the Construction Law, which is a 24-month warranty.

Along with that, as for the management responsibility of the management board, the codes have not addressed it and there are no sanctions to handle clear violations by the management board.

In addition, on the story of renovating old apartments: This is a hot spot in urban development, so renovating old apartments cannot be avoided. I think the Ministry of Construction, which specializes in this issue, should organize a meeting with the relevant agencies to turn the renovation of old apartment housing into a special issue that urgently needs to be unblocked.

Dr. Nguyen Quang Tuyen, Vice Chairman of the Council of Hanoi Law University, also said that the legal system on real estate business still has some bottlenecks to be removed in order to help restore the development of the real estate market after the Covid-19 pandemic.

To do so, according to Mr. Tuyen, it is necessary to study and assess in order to identify the bottlenecks among several laws directly related to the real estate market, including: the 2013 Land Law, the 2013 Law on Bidding, the 2015 Housing Law, the 2009 Law on Urban Planning and the 2014 Law on Real Estate Business.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Nguyen Quang Tuyen, Vice Chairman of the School Council of Hanoi Law University, presents his paper

“On the other hand, the contradictions in current codes include many unsuitable points, but they should also be assessed on the positive side and not viewed negatively. Because the market is experiencing fluctuations, and as it moves into a new phase there will be things in the law that are not reasonable and need amending,” Mr. Tuyen emphasized.

Related articles

    Sign up to receive project details

    Price list, sales contract, loan policy, latest promotions.


    Please fill in the information completely to receive the most accurate project information

     

    en_USEnglish